Bhagavad Gita 18.28 — The Tāmasic Doer: Undisciplined, Stubborn, and Procrastinating
अयुक्तः प्राकृतः स्तब्धः शठो नैष्कृतिकोऽलसः ।
विषादी दीर्घसूत्री च कर्ता तामस उच्यते ॥ १८.२८ ॥
🔊 Listen to meaning of this shloka
Current voice: —
Ready
Text-to-speech is not supported by this browser.
A doer who is undisciplined, uncultured, stubborn, deceitful, malicious, lazy, despondent, and procrastinating is called tāmasic (of the nature of ignorance).
Transliteration (IAST)
Word Separation
The Sanskrit verse is separated into individual words (Padched) for easier study.
Word Meanings
| Line 1 | |
|---|---|
| Sanskrit Word | Meaning |
| ayuktaḥ | undisciplined, unsteady |
| prākṛtaḥ | uncultured, vulgar |
| stabdhaḥ | obstinate, stubborn |
| śhaṭhaḥ | deceitful, crafty |
| naiṣhkṛtikaḥ | malicious, dishonest |
| alasaḥ | lazy |
| Line 2 | |
|---|---|
| Sanskrit Word | Meaning |
| viṣhādī | despondent, gloomy |
| dīrghasūtrī | procrastinating |
| cha | and |
| kartā | the doer |
| tāmasaḥ | tāmasic, of the nature of ignorance |
| uchyate | is called |
| Line 1 | Line 2 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Sanskrit Word | Meaning | Sanskrit Word | Meaning |
| ayuktaḥ | undisciplined, unsteady | viṣhādī | despondent, gloomy |
| prākṛtaḥ | uncultured, vulgar | dīrghasūtrī | procrastinating |
| stabdhaḥ | obstinate, stubborn | cha | and |
| śhaṭhaḥ | deceitful, crafty | kartā | the doer |
| naiṣhkṛtikaḥ | malicious, dishonest | tāmasaḥ | tāmasic, of the nature of ignorance |
| alasaḥ | lazy | uchyate | is called |
Detailed Meaning
Introduction
Here Lord Krishna describes the <em>tāmasic</em> doer. This person is undisciplined, uncultured, obstinate, deceitful, lazy, despondent, and given to endless delay.
Essence
Work under the influence of inertia
The third kind of doer is one in whom tamas dominates. This verse lists a series of qualities that together paint a picture of a person who cannot work well, or cannot be trusted to.
Ayuktaḥ (undisciplined, unsteady): The mind is not trained or focused. There is no inner order, and the person cannot hold to a purpose.
Prākṛtaḥ (unrefined, uncultured): There has been no refinement of understanding or behaviour. The person acts on raw impulse, without the polish that learning and reflection bring.
Stabdhaḥ (stubborn, rigid): The person resists advice, correction, and change, and will not bend even when wrong.
Śaṭhaḥ (deceitful): Instead of putting honest effort, the person tries to get by through cunning or evasion.
Naiṣkṛtikaḥ (dishonest, malicious, or insulting): The person may undermine others, or treat their efforts with contempt, in order to cover personal inadequacy.
Alasaḥ (lazy): Inertia prevents action even when action is clearly needed.
Viṣādī (despondent): A heaviness of mind settles in, so that tasks are approached with gloom and a sense of hopelessness.
Dīrgha-sūtrī (procrastinating): Everything is put off. The thread of work is stretched endlessly, and tasks that could be finished in a day drag on for months.
Understanding rather than condemning
It is worth remembering that the three guṇas are present in all of us, so this verse is not meant to condemn anyone permanently. It is a diagnostic. Most people will recognise some of these tendencies in themselves at certain times, particularly the habit of delay and the low mood that comes with it. The purpose of recognising them is to begin moving out of them.
Message for Everyday Life (Breaking the Habit of Delay)
Procrastination, low motivation, and stubborn refusal to learn can all trap a person in a cycle in which the heaviness feeds itself.
A first step: Choose the smallest piece of a postponed task and complete it today. Action is the best remedy for inertia, because a little momentum begins to lift the heaviness. Also seek honest feedback and listen to it, since openness to correction directly weakens stubbornness.
Work under the influence of inertia
The third kind of doer is one in whom tamas dominates. This verse lists a series of qualities that together paint a picture of a person who cannot work well, or cannot be trusted to.
Ayuktaḥ (undisciplined, unsteady): The mind is not trained or focused. There is no inner order, and the person cannot hold to a purpose.
Prākṛtaḥ (unrefined, uncultured): There has been no refinement of understanding or behaviour. The person acts on raw impulse, without the polish that learning and reflection bring.
Stabdhaḥ (stubborn, rigid): The person resists advice, correction, and change, and will not bend even when wrong.
Śaṭhaḥ (deceitful): Instead of putting honest effort, the person tries to get by through cunning or evasion.
Naiṣkṛtikaḥ (dishonest, malicious, or insulting): The person may undermine others, or treat their efforts with contempt, in order to cover personal inadequacy.
Alasaḥ (lazy): Inertia prevents action even when action is clearly needed.
Viṣādī (despondent): A heaviness of mind settles in, so that tasks are approached with gloom and a sense of hopelessness.
Dīrgha-sūtrī (procrastinating): Everything is put off. The thread of work is stretched endlessly, and tasks that could be finished in a day drag on for months.
Understanding rather than condemning
It is worth remembering that the three guṇas are present in all of us, so this verse is not meant to condemn anyone permanently. It is a diagnostic. Most people will recognise some of these tendencies in themselves at certain times, particularly the habit of delay and the low mood that comes with it. The purpose of recognising them is to begin moving out of them.
Message for Everyday Life (Breaking the Habit of Delay)
Procrastination, low motivation, and stubborn refusal to learn can all trap a person in a cycle in which the heaviness feeds itself.
A first step: Choose the smallest piece of a postponed task and complete it today. Action is the best remedy for inertia, because a little momentum begins to lift the heaviness. Also seek honest feedback and listen to it, since openness to correction directly weakens stubbornness.
Next Topic
Lord Krishna has completed the threefold description of the doer. In the next verse, He turns to two inner faculties that govern all action, <em>buddhi</em> (understanding) and <em>dhṛti</em> (firmness), and announces that they too are of three kinds.
Hidden Messages In This Shloka
Reflect on this verse from different perspectives and see which deeper message opens up for you.
Wisdom Nuggets
Small steady steps defeat large lazy intentions.
Cunning wins the moment and loses the person.
Begin, and the energy follows.
Despair is a mood, not a verdict.
Tomorrow is a crowded place for postponed duties.
Stubbornness cannot learn.
Any day can mark a return to steadiness.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does 'ayuktaḥ' (undisciplined) mean here?
What do 'śhaṭhaḥ' (deceitful) and 'naiṣhkṛtikaḥ' (malicious) show about the 'tāmasa' (of the nature of ignorance) doer?
What is meant by 'dīrghasūtrī' (procrastinating)?
Is feeling 'viṣhādī' (despondent) always a sign of 'tamas' (the quality of ignorance and inertia)?
What is the practical message of this verse in one sentence?
Explore related topics
More shlokas on the themes this verse touches: