Bhagavad Gita 18.59 — A False Resolve: Your Own Nature Will Compel You to Act
यदहङ्कारमाश्रित्य न योत्स्य इति मन्यसे ।
मिथ्यैष व्यवसायस्ते प्रकृतिस्त्वां नियोक्ष्यति ॥ १८.५९ ॥
🔊 Listen to meaning of this shloka
Current voice: —
Ready
Text-to-speech is not supported by this browser.
If, relying on egoism, you think, 'I will not fight,' this resolve of yours is false; your own nature will compel you.
Transliteration (IAST)
Word Separation
The Sanskrit verse is separated into individual words (Padched) for easier study.
Word Meanings
| Line 1 | |
|---|---|
| Sanskrit Word | Meaning |
| yat | if |
| ahaṅkāram | egoism |
| āśhritya | relying on, taking shelter of |
| na | not |
| yotsye | I will fight |
| iti | thus |
| manyase | you think |
| Line 2 | |
|---|---|
| Sanskrit Word | Meaning |
| mithyā | false, vain |
| eṣhaḥ | this |
| vyavasāyaḥ | resolve, determination |
| te | your |
| prakṛtiḥ | nature |
| tvām | you |
| niyokṣhyati | will compel, will engage |
| Line 1 | Line 2 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Sanskrit Word | Meaning | Sanskrit Word | Meaning |
| yat | if | mithyā | false, vain |
| ahaṅkāram | egoism | eṣhaḥ | this |
| āśhritya | relying on, taking shelter of | vyavasāyaḥ | resolve, determination |
| na | not | te | your |
| yotsye | I will fight | prakṛtiḥ | nature |
| iti | thus | tvām | you |
| manyase | you think | niyokṣhyati | will compel, will engage |
Detailed Meaning
Introduction
Here Lord Krishna directly addresses Arjuna's decision. He says that if, relying on ego, Arjuna thinks that he will not fight, then his resolve is false, because his own nature will compel him to act.
Essence
Examining a decision made from ego
The Gita began with Arjuna declaring that he would not fight. Now, at the end of the teaching, Lord Krishna returns to that statement and examines it honestly.
Yad ahaṅkāram āśritya (relying on ego): The key phrase is ahaṅkāram āśritya, taking shelter in ego. Lord Krishna is saying that Arjuna's refusal is not based on clear understanding, but on a self-centred stance. It is the ego that says, I will not do this. I will decide what is right for me.
Na yotsya iti manyase (you think, I will not fight): The word manyase means you think or imagine. It suggests that the decision exists in Arjuna's mind as a mental position rather than as a genuine and settled truth.
Mithyā eṣa vyavasāyas te (this resolve of yours is false): The word vyavasāya means determination. Lord Krishna calls it mithyā, false or unfounded. It will not hold, because it is not rooted in reality.
Prakṛtis tvāṁ niyokṣyati (your own nature will compel you): Arjuna is by temperament a warrior. His entire disposition inclines him toward courage and duty, and it will pull him back into action, whatever he may declare in a moment of confusion.
The gap between ego and nature
This verse points to a gap that many of us experience, between what our ego announces and what our deeper nature actually demands. We may declare that we will give up something or take up something, but the declaration falls apart because it was never in harmony with who we really are.
Lord Krishna is not forcing Arjuna. He is helping him see that a resolution made from wounded pride and emotional confusion is unlikely to stand.
Message for Everyday Life (Decisions Made in the Heat of the Moment)
When we are upset, overwhelmed, or hurt, we often make sweeping decisions, such as quitting, cutting people off, or giving up on a goal. Later, we find ourselves drawn back, because the decision came from emotion and ego and not from understanding.
A helpful pause: Before acting on a major decision made in a charged moment, wait until the emotion has settled and ask whether the decision still seems right when your mind is calm.
Examining a decision made from ego
The Gita began with Arjuna declaring that he would not fight. Now, at the end of the teaching, Lord Krishna returns to that statement and examines it honestly.
Yad ahaṅkāram āśritya (relying on ego): The key phrase is ahaṅkāram āśritya, taking shelter in ego. Lord Krishna is saying that Arjuna's refusal is not based on clear understanding, but on a self-centred stance. It is the ego that says, I will not do this. I will decide what is right for me.
Na yotsya iti manyase (you think, I will not fight): The word manyase means you think or imagine. It suggests that the decision exists in Arjuna's mind as a mental position rather than as a genuine and settled truth.
Mithyā eṣa vyavasāyas te (this resolve of yours is false): The word vyavasāya means determination. Lord Krishna calls it mithyā, false or unfounded. It will not hold, because it is not rooted in reality.
Prakṛtis tvāṁ niyokṣyati (your own nature will compel you): Arjuna is by temperament a warrior. His entire disposition inclines him toward courage and duty, and it will pull him back into action, whatever he may declare in a moment of confusion.
The gap between ego and nature
This verse points to a gap that many of us experience, between what our ego announces and what our deeper nature actually demands. We may declare that we will give up something or take up something, but the declaration falls apart because it was never in harmony with who we really are.
Lord Krishna is not forcing Arjuna. He is helping him see that a resolution made from wounded pride and emotional confusion is unlikely to stand.
Message for Everyday Life (Decisions Made in the Heat of the Moment)
When we are upset, overwhelmed, or hurt, we often make sweeping decisions, such as quitting, cutting people off, or giving up on a goal. Later, we find ourselves drawn back, because the decision came from emotion and ego and not from understanding.
A helpful pause: Before acting on a major decision made in a charged moment, wait until the emotion has settled and ask whether the decision still seems right when your mind is calm.
Next Topic
Lord Krishna has said that Arjuna's own nature will compel him to act. In the next verse, He explains this further: being bound by the duty born of his nature, Arjuna will end up doing, even helplessly, the very thing that he now refuses out of delusion.
Hidden Messages In This Shloka
Reflect on this verse from different perspectives and see which deeper message opens up for you.
Wisdom Nuggets
Check where your 'no' is coming from.
You cannot long outrun who you are.
Ego can sound like wisdom.
Know your real motive.
Strong words are not always strong decisions.
What fits you will call you back.
Choices that fit your nature endure.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does 'ahaṅkāram āśhritya' (relying on egoism) mean in this verse?
What does 'mithyā vyavasāyaḥ' (a false resolve) mean?
What does 'prakṛtiḥ tvām niyokṣhyati' (your nature will compel you) mean?
Is Krishna saying that human beings have no choice?
What is the practical message of this verse in one sentence?
Explore related topics
More shlokas on the themes this verse touches: